Black eyeliner is the quintessential makeup piece that everyone should own. Smudge it with your finger or eyeshadow for a natural or smokey eye or draw a thick line for a defined and bold look.
Either way, feel comfortable knowing that a Red Apple Eyeliner is not going to give you any weird reactions - it won't smudge - and it won't leave you with raccoon eyes at the end of the day!
Posted by Rebecca Forrest on 22nd Apr 2014
While it might be good for my skin, the one I got is not creamy and does not draw on smoothly. Could be my age (we shall say I’m just under 60).
I expect something really nice if I'm paying 23.00 for a pencil.
Some eyelid skins are thinner and unless that pencil really is creamy, it just pulls on that soft tissue and makes anything but a nice fine line!
I gave it the extra star just because it has healthy ingredients. But it has to go back.
Posted by Patty on 21st Apr 2014
Fantastic, I recommend this product.
Posted by Patrice on 15th Apr 2014
The eyeliner is really easy to put on and creates a perfectly smooth line!
Posted by Sharon McRae on 11th Apr 2014
I've tried this just once so far, over the new eye primer, and if have to say I was super impressed! It was pretty easy to apply, no dragging or smearing, and gave just the right intensity of color. I usually use the black RAL shallow as a liner, but wanted to try something a bit quicker and more portable as an alternate option. Over the primer, it stayed in place all day, even through crying when I chopped onions (which I do a lot since I'm a busy mom and I teach plant-based cooking classes)! Easy to remove, as well. Definitely will keep this in my rotation, and for super lasting power, I'm going to try layering the black shadow over it. Thanks for another great product, RAL,
Posted by Sharon Eachus on 7th Apr 2014
I seem to be having problems with the eyeliner. I love the way it is soft and smooth and goes on easily. However, it smudges easily and I have to reapply it a lot! My skin seems to love to absorb it. For this reason I have to give it a 3 instead of a 5 - I am sad.
Posted by Kelsey on 3rd Apr 2014
I LOVE this eyeliner! I have very sensitive eyes and eye lids, and this eyeliner didn't bother them one bit. I like it because you can smudge it a bit to give it a nice smokey look. This is the only eyeliner I'll ever buy again!
Posted by Unknown on 2nd Apr 2014
This pencil was hard to use and the color is murky.
Posted by Shanah McKnight on 1st Apr 2014
This is one of the best eyeliners by far. On a daily basis, I only apply liner to my bottom lids. The problem with most liners is that I end up with raccoon eyes by 2pm. That is not the case with RAL's pencil; it lasts clear into the evening (even after the gym). I honestly was surprised due to the fact it is hard for me to find a liner that stays put. I've found a keeper!
Posted by Sharon E on 23rd Mar 2014
Love Love Love this eyeliner. Doesn't make my eyes water or itch. Goes on smooth and SOFT. Unlike some eyeliner pencils that HURT when you use them. Also, washes off without a lot of scrubbing! Thank you
Posted by Kellie on 15th Mar 2014
I love this eyeliner! It is the smoothest applying eyeliner I have ever used .Goes on very easy.