Black eyeliner is the quintessential makeup piece that everyone should own. Smudge it with your finger or eyeshadow for a natural or smokey eye or draw a thick line for a defined and bold look.
Either way, feel comfortable knowing that a Red Apple Eyeliner is not going to give you any weird reactions - it won't smudge - and it won't leave you with raccoon eyes at the end of the day!
Posted by Unknown on 8th Jun 2014
I was a fan when I tried this eyeliner for the first time. It was long lasting and I like that it was gluten free. When I tried to sharpen this pencil, I wasted half of the pencil because it kept crumbling. It was a brand new sharpener, so I don't know what the problem was. Any advice on how to sharpen this or what type of sharpener to use?...
Posted by LR on 6th Jun 2014
This is very creamy. Goes on fairly easily, but smudges easily.
The point doesn't hold up well since it is so creamy.
Will have to see how it does if first apply Prime Time eye primer.
Posted by Jody Liu on 9th May 2014
I love that this product is natural and is made of safe ingredients, especially since it is something I put very very close to my eyes~ I also like that it is pigmented and the simple fact that it glides on easily.
However, I didnt like that it isnt smudge-proof. In a weather as hot and humid as Singapore, this eyeliner starting smudging in less than 1 hour and I ended up with raccoon eyes! Hahaha~ That's a big nono for me :(
So now, I use it as a base for smokey look~ works and last longer for smokey eye makeup!
Posted by Unknown on 9th May 2014
Love that this is gluten free. It doesn't make my eyes water. Has great color and last all day.
Posted by Sharon Eachus on 29th Apr 2014
I ordered the Eye Liner for 5 other women besides myself. Here are some of the reviews I received. Absolutely loved it. It stayed on better then my other one does. Needs a lot of sharpening, maybe they could put it in the same type of tube as the lip pencil where you twist it up and make the actual liner that small - would need less sharpening then. Smears to easy, but liked it, goes on very nice and lasts all day- I would buy it again. It doesn't hurt to apply like my hard pencil. Still waiting on two o more reviews from two of the ladies. Will post those when I get them.
Posted by Unknown on 29th Apr 2014
The best thing about this eyeliner is that I can use it on the inside of my eye and not get blurred vision!! It goes on smooth and draws very nice. I love it and will only use this from now on. Sharpens beautifully too!
Posted by Emily on 29th Apr 2014
I use a black powder eyeliner for a softer everyday look, but use this pencil on top of the softer black powder to darken up the line and give the appearance of thicker lashes and bigger eyes for a night out. This works great to do "cat eyes" as well. It goes on very easily, smoothly, and evenly. I will be buying this again and again.
Posted by Rebecca Forrest on 22nd Apr 2014
While it might be good for my skin, the one I got is not creamy and does not draw on smoothly. Could be my age (we shall say I’m just under 60).
I expect something really nice if I'm paying 23.00 for a pencil.
Some eyelid skins are thinner and unless that pencil really is creamy, it just pulls on that soft tissue and makes anything but a nice fine line!
I gave it the extra star just because it has healthy ingredients. But it has to go back.
Posted by Patty on 21st Apr 2014
Fantastic, I recommend this product.
Posted by Patrice on 15th Apr 2014
The eyeliner is really easy to put on and creates a perfectly smooth line!