Our eye shadows are crafted with care to be gentle and vibrant, perfect for those with sensitive skin. Made without talc and unnecessary additives, these eye shadows are designed to provide beautiful color while minimizing the risk of irritation. With high-quality ingredients like mica and zinc oxide, you can enjoy a comfortable and colorful experience. Explore our range and find the perfect shade for your style.
Buttercream
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
38 Reviews
Buttercream
$13
Rated 4.9 out of 5 stars
38 Reviews
Earn 13 Reward Points on your order.
Order by midnight tonight for delivery by :
October 31
Earn 10% cash back on every purchase.
Make The Smart Switch To Our Refillable Eyeshadow Palettes
This is a refill pan designed for our magnetic, refillable eyeshadow palette system — created to end the frustration of traditional palettes.
Tired of running out of your most-used shade while the rest sit untouched? We were too.
Our refillable palettes are different: choose the shades you wear, refill only what you use, and never waste space (or money) on colors that aren't for you.
Simplify Your Routine, Declutter Your Drawer, and Never Be Without The Shades You Love
Talc-Free
Super Pigmented
Made For Itchy Eyes
Vegan & Cruelty Free
Easily Blendable
For Use In Refillable Palettes
All About Eyes
TAKE YOUR EYES FROM BLAH TO WOW
Additional Information
38 reviews
- ACAnne C.Verified BuyerReviewingButtercreamI recommend this productWhat's your age range? 60-69What's your beauty style? Classic, NaturalRated 5 out of 5 stars1 month agoBeautiful Color
Color is beautiful! Coverage takes some getting used to likely due to the fact that it doesn’t contain ingredients my other eye shadows do!
- SFSusan F.Verified BuyerReviewingButtercreamI recommend this productWhat's your age range? 70+What's your beauty style? Low MaintenanceRated 5 out of 5 stars3 months agoNice eye shadow
Red Apple eye shadow are the best out there. No irritation and goes on smooth
- CCCindy C.Verified BuyerReviewingButtercreamI recommend this productWhat's your age range? 60-69What's your beauty style? Natural, Classic, Low MaintenanceRated 5 out of 5 stars5 months agoPerfect for Browbone
Great neutral shade for brow bone highlight area.
- MLMary L. R.Verified BuyerReviewingButtercreamI recommend this productWhat's your age range? 60-69What's your beauty style? NaturalRated 5 out of 5 stars5 months agoJust Like Creamy Butter!
This shade goes on beautifully and stays on. It is especially good for highlighting under the brow bone.
- AWArlen W. J.Verified BuyerReviewingButtercreamI recommend this productWhat's your age range? 70+Rated 5 out of 5 stars10 months agoEyeshadow
My wife loves the eyeshadow. Her eyes don’t water near as much as they did with other eyeshadows.