Black Eyeliner Pencil by Red Apple

4.41 out of 5

$23.00

In stock

Purchase this product now and earn 23 Points! Learn More

Return Policy: 6 Months

This eyeliner is designed without the yucky ingredients that cause allergic reactions and watery, puffy, itchy, red eyes.
Moisturizing and smooth – this pencil will glide against your lash line, which naturally makes your eyelashes look thicker and fuller at the base.
You will love the soft black color of this pencil – it will perfectly define your eyes – no muss no fuss!

ingredientsymbols

SKU: EP-1.

Black eyeliner is the quintessential makeup piece that everyone should own. Smudge it with your finger or eyeshadow for a natural or smokey eye or draw a thick line for a defined and bold look.

Either way, feel comfortable knowing that a Red Apple Eyeliner is not going to give you any weird reactions – it won’t smudge – and it won’t leave you with raccoon eyes at the end of the day!


Weight 0.25 oz
Dimensions 5 x .25 x .25 in
Allergen Information

Corn Free, Cruelty Free, Dairy Free, Nut Free / Fragrance Free, Petroleum Free, Soy Free


Each Red Apple Lipstick Product is hand crafted in the USA from the finest, highest quality materials available.

Each lineup has a slightly different set of ingredients and all cosmetics are lab tested 100% gluten free.

(net wt. .04 oz/1g)

Helianthus annus (Sunflower) seed oil, Synthetic Bees Wax, Copernicia Cerifera Wax, Rhus Succedanea Fruit Wax, GF Tocopheryl Acetate, Mica, Iron Oxides


Share your thoughts!

4.41 out of 5 stars

83 reviews

Help Another Woman By Posting Your Product Review Today. You can even add a picture or a video, it's fun!

What others are saying

  1. Carrie

    5 out of 5 Love this black eyeliner!!

    Carrie

    I have very sensitive skin and I have no problems with this eyeliner. I love it and highly recommend it!!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  2. 5 out of 5 It’s bold

    Tajinder

    This eyeliner is bold black but runny and runs down thru eye lashes

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  3. 5 out of 5 Black eyeliner pencil

    Gloria Kedzior

    This is my second time buying this eyeliner. It goes on smoothly without tugging. This is important for mature eyes. The color is bold but not harsh. It stays all day and doesn’t smudge. It lasts a long time, doesn’t break easily and can be sharpened to the end. I am 65 and have tried many eyeliners. This is by far my favorite!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  4. McKenna

    3 out of 5 Good product, but not dark black

    McKenna

    This product is good if you are going for a Smokey look. It doesn’t do hard lines well, and has more of a grey undertone. I was looking for a black crisp line, so this product didn’t deliver what I was looking for.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  5. 5 out of 5 Black Eyeliner

    Carrie

    I have been looking for a natural eyeliner that doesn’t smear, and this is by far the best one I’ve tried. I think my search is finally over.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  6. 5 out of 5 Back to Black

    stacey

    This black eyeliner goes on smooth. Looking forward to ordering other shades.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  7. 5 out of 5 Great eyeliner!

    Maryann Gallagher

    Love this eyeliner for everyday. Good staying power as well especially compared to other natural brands.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  8. 4 out of 5 Soft Formula

    hwiper

    It’s hard to get both a dark and even line with this, but it is still a good eyeliner. I mostly use it on my water line, and it stays well there.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  9. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Stays in place

    SHARON

    This black liner goes on very soft yet the staying power is very strong. On my upper lid I am able to easily blend if I want, or wear a solid heavier line. I also wear it on my lower lid. I can wear this liner for many hours without worrying that it will smudge. The liner stays in place and does not run.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  10. One person found this helpful

    4 out of 5 Great natural liner

    Allison

    I recently have been switching my products to all natural and organic as I am a red head with fair skin and sensitivities. I haven’t been wearing any makeup until I received these products because of the way conventional makeup burned my eyes. This eyeliner is great. At first, it didn’t want to go on very smooth, but once it got it going, it went on very smooth and pigmented. It does smudge a bit from time to time, but what makeup doesn’t? The corner of your eyes get wet and any natural product isn’t going to be perfect. But I love that I found this company and I will continue to use their products.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  11. 5 out of 5 Nice and smooth

    Lisa

    This is my first purchase of any eyeliner outside of Sisley. It is soft and smooth. The color is very very black. Hopefully it will not smudge time will tell. But so far I really like it.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  12. 2 out of 5 Black eyeliner pencil

    Lynn

    I’m a fan of the lipsticks, and thought I would try the eyeliner. I would not recommend it. This eyeliner smears very easily. I’m constantly wiping away smudges both under my eyes and above my eyelids. I wouldn’t buy again.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  13. 5 out of 5 Black Eyeliner Pencil

    Sandra

    I can’t live without eyeliner. Black is my favorite color, and I never leave home without it. When I had to change to gluten free products, I was relieved to find a product that I could use that looks good. For the first time, my eyes don’t itch. Excellent product.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  14. 4 out of 5 Black Eyeliner Pencil

    Kerri

    This is a great pencil! It goes on smoothly and stays in place. Sometimes I have to blot the outer crease if it’s “running” later in the day. I feel good about putting a makeup on that won’t bother my eyes. I would order this again.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  15. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Great eyeliner!

    Kathy

    Love this eyeliner! It stays in place and doesn’t smudge. And I’m so excited to have found an eyeliner that doesn’t irritate my eyes! I have had to quit wearing eye makeup because my eyes have become so sensitive to make up and I just couldn’t find anything that would work. So excited to have found Red Apple!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  16. One person found this helpful

    4 out of 5 Great pencil

    Melissa

    So I wanted to wait a bit to write the review, testing it into spring allergy season. This pencil is indeed amazing. I got it because I am allergic to everything it seems. I stopped wearing eye make up for two months, including eyeliner; my eyes were always in pain and I even went to the ophthalmologist concerned it was truly serious. Then I found this company. I’ve been trying one product at a time. Love the mascara. Then I added the pencil. No itching, no eye pain– it feels fantastic. It helps me feel like me again. I love makeup and not wearing eye makeup was horrible. My students thought I was sick. Finding the RedAppleLipstick company has helped me so much. So to sum up, I highly recommend the pencil to sensitive eyes and will be ordering the shadows next. I do have to touch up and reapply mid-day but that is not really a problem. It’s just not ideal. But it goes on nicely and is easy to smudge for that smokier look. My one wish: more colors. A blue, plum and brown would be awesome to have.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  17. 5 out of 5 Works for me

    hilary

    I’m not big on eyeliner because I am very sensitive to having anything around my eyes, but I trust RAL’s products so I decided to give it a try. I find this eyeliner to be easy to apply, non-irritating, and stays without smudging. I like it! Update: I wear this regularly now and I love it.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  18. One person found this helpful

    3 out of 5 Not my favorite

    Tamarielpaints

    I find that this eyeliner “migrates” from the waterline and makes a mess. It’s not smudgeproof or waterproof. The black isn’t as powerful as I hoped. I also found this eyeliner pencil “pokey” (more so than the eggplant one I have from them). For a $23 product I would have expected it to behave better.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  19. 3 out of 3 people found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Best Eyeliner Ever, Hands Down!

    Jahna

    I was a little skeptical switching from my long lasting, drug store eye liners. I have tried so many eye liners, I swear I should be doing YouTube reviews. I had been a loyal “Almay ColorStay Eye Liner” user for years. I don’t know if I have oily skin or what but I can never seem to keep my eye liner from smudging. The Almay was the only one I used that would stay. After I had my son 2 years ago, I became allergic to many of the products I had used for years. After some research I started to realize just how bad the ingredients are in most products you buy at the drug store or even high-end like Sephora’s or Ulta. My eyes were always red, blood-shot, itchy and I just stopped wearing makeup all-together. When I learned about more natural options I tried 100 Percent Pure Eye Pencil first. It smudges pretty bad on me and I decided to try something else. I found Red Apple through a YouTube review of a natural, vegan YouTuber. I gave this pencil a try in the Black color. It came in last night, I put it on this morning and we are now in a committed relationship. It stayed on better than any eye liner I have ever used before in my life, my eyes were not irritated AT ALL. It felt like I wasn’t wearing it and it did not budge at all. Probably because I wasn’t itching my eyes like I normally do. You have my attention Red Apple. 🙂 <3

    Lipstick: Gypsy Soul
    Eyeliner: Black
    Lash Project Mascara in Black

    (3) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  20. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Best Kohl-style Eyeliner I've Used

    Michelle

    I am thrilled to finally find a pencil eyeliner that stays. My eyes tear more often than I’d like, are highly sensitive…emphasis on highly sensitive, turn red and swollen at the slightest irritation….and this eyeliner works for me! I have had no reactions to wearing this pencil and it wears exceptionally well. I have used it along the top lash line as well as the lower lash line and it stays all day without smearing. When first applying each time I am aware that the pencil almost needs to warm up to go on smoothly on the upper lash line but after a couple of strokes it applies more smoothly and is not an issue; that is not a negative against the pencil for me as the alternative would be a super soft pencil and those are the style that smear and smudge. I will be purchasing this pencil in more colors just for the fun of it since I know they won’t smear. I have not found this quality of pencil at any level until now, so it pays to keep trying them out until you find one you like. I have used this loyally since I first tried it and this is the only black pencil liner I will use.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  21. 2 out of 2 people found this helpful

    4 out of 5 Love The Black Eyeliner But...

    Niya

    For this to be an all natural eyeliner I had a great experience for the most part with this. I often run into trouble with eyeliners (natural or not) smearing down at the outer corners of my eyes and it would make me look tired and/or like I had a long day. This eyeliner does not BUT my problem with the eyeliner is when I get a little less than half way down the pencil, it all of a sudden requires a lot f sharpening but it’s not sharpening well. It starts to perform like a cheap 99 cents eyeliner rather than a $23 performance. I was irritated (as I was getting ready for work mind you) that the crayon (for lack of a better word) didn’t extend nearly all the way down the pencil. A little less than half way down the crayon stopped, so I definitely feel cheated because I’ve paid for expensive eyeliner before and the crayon extended nearly all the way down the pencil . I figured that must be why while sharpening as the pencil is a little less than half way down it’s hardly sharpening and nearly crumbling. I purchased it again anyway hoping that the previous was just defective. Other than that I think the pencil has great staying power but I hope you guys fix that issue in the pencil.

    (2) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  22. One person found this helpful

    4 out of 5 Love it

    Maya

    I do have to say i love this, after years and years i finally found an eyeliner to put on my eyes that does not make my eyes blood red, puffy, itching, and end up giving me an headache a few hours later. The only thing that makes it not perfect, is the fact that it won’t stay on my water line, it moves down to my eyelash and under eye area leaving the water line almost “empty”… It’s not a huge deal, however it’s the only reason i don’t give this 5 stars! Because i do love this liner!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  23. 5 out of 5 The best

    Michelle merrigan

    I love the cocoa eyeliner. I use it every day. Soft, easy to put on and it stays!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  24. One person found this helpful

    4 out of 5 Good but frustrating to sharpen

    JJ

    I love this eyeliner, it’s great so far, no allergy issues, no desire to scratch my eyes out, and it looks awesome! My one frustration is that sharpening it can be a real issue. It breaks, a lot. It then has to be sharpened more and the wood gets broken, and it becomes a mess. Today I had to repeat the sharpening process so much I actually lost out on a good month or more of use from this pencil and that is frustrating for my pocketbook. 🙁

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  25. 4 out of 5 Finally a GF eyeliner Pencil I love

    Kara

    I have tried some other GF eyeliners, but none really worked well for me. I especially didn’t like using powder eyeliner. This pencil is great! It goes on smooth and it can be a bit lighter or darker depending on how you apply it. The only thing I have a problem with is sometimes by afternoon I need to wipe under my eyes a bit. Not bad though.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  26. One person found this helpful
    eewolfer

    5 out of 5 Great for me and my little dancer

    eewolfer

    I love this liner. I use it daily. If I want a more natural look, I will brush a lighter eye shadow over it, like grey, and of course if I want a dark look I put it on very thick and go over it with a sparkly black shadow to enhance it. I also use this for my daughter at dance competitions and am so thankful to have something that is natural that I can feel comfortable using on her eyes. She is prone to getting styes and has had no issues at all with this eye liner.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  27. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Great eyeliner

    Tiffany

    Many eyeliners cause contact dermatitis when I use them (redness, swelling, itching at the lash line). I’ve been using this eyeliner for over a month and I’m so happy to say I have had no problems!! Yeah for RAL!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  28. 5 out of 5 Eyeliner Ecstasy!

    Constance

    I am in my 60s and had given up on eyeliners. They didn’t stay in place, and irritated my eyes. Decided to give this one a try, and it has become one of my essential products everyday. Thanks for a great product!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  29. stephanie_beltz

    5 out of 5

    stephanie_beltz

    Aside from its designed function as an eyeliner, this works for a nice gray/black lip in emergency situations! I looked all over for a black lipstick for my Raven costume and tried my eyeliner with some ralleye balm. Perfect.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  30. 5 out of 5 True Black

    jlstierney

    This is a true black eyeliner. It goes on smooth and does not smear all day. To soften the color or change the look you can put a RAL eyeshadow right over it. It is a great pencil that last a long time even with daily use.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  31. 5 out of 5 Eye Liner Pencil

    Alexis

    This liner doesn’t make my eye lids itch like some others I’ve tried. I am an eye rubber and it is nice to not worry about getting gluten on my fingers and then in my mouth. Nice glide-on color.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  32. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 No Itchy Eyes!!

    Nicole

    I have pretty much stopped wearing makeup until I found these products. I am a little skeptical so slowly…..but surely I am trying their products one by one. I am a HUGE fan of all of the lip stuff I’ve tried. No more cracked lips.

    When it comes to my eyes I’ve been hesitant because in the past I would get itching, burning, bumps, infections and all sorts of craziness from the products I was using. When this pencil arrived the other day I decided to plunge right in and try it right away…….and this is what I noticed:

    1. The pencil was was soft! No hard pointy pencil where you practically poke through your eye to get color. Went on smoothly!

    2. Color is vibrant. Did not need to keep coloring to get a black line.

    3. Long lasting. I put this on early about 6:00 am and when I got home around 7pm it looked like it did when I left the house! Just and FYI I was not wearing any eye shadow, just the liner.

    4. NO issues with itching or any of the problems I would normally have by the end of the day. Its day three that I am wearing this and am sooooooo happy!!! Thank you!

    I have only one suggestion – a smudger would be nice on the end. Other than that, I am completely satisfied and will next try the navy color!

    If you are reading this and have not tried any of their products – I’d say take a shot. I have major allergies and have problems with all makeup and body products. Red Apple has a fan in ME!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  33. 4 out of 5 Great liner!

    Unknown

    Love the eyeliner. Did not tear up, no irritation. Do you have plans for foundation ( especially for black women)?

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  34. 2 out of 5 Doesn't Last

    Amanda

    The eyeliner is nice for my ultra-sensitive eyes, but it does not last for very long.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  35. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 I'm all red apple from now on!

    Reb

    Second order of both eye pencil and mascara. I
    knew I loved them but when I tried going back to my old products just
    long enough to order new red apple; after one application my eyes itched
    and ran for 3 days! I have had the same experience with the
    lipsticks.. I’m all red apple from now on!

    I also quite like spending my money at a company of committed, caring people.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  36. One person found this helpful

    2 out of 5 Dissapointed

    Diana Swift

    I have been attempting to us, but find myself very reluctant. This Pencil drags on my eyes, and stutters its way across the eye, leaving a much too wide line. I end up with owl eyes. I am disappointed, and would like to return the product.

    (0) (1)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  37. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Best Eyeliner Ever

    Brenda

    This is the best eyeliner ever. As soon as I began using it, my eyes no longer itched or were red and they do not run like they used to. It stays on well, even with my runny eyes. Thank you!!!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  38. 5 out of 5 Perfect

    Judy

    This liner is so smooth and creamy. It just glides on and stays put. It’s very easy to take off at the end of the day.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  39. 5 out of 5 Fantastic

    Lynne W.

    I was reluctant to purchase because this is a black eyeliner, and I usually wear softer colors. This pencil has the capability of being the softest black, and is a wonderful “base” to apply my RAL shadows for incredible staying power. It is *so nice* to apply a pencil and not have it cause my eyes to itch and water. I highly recommend it.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  40. 5 out of 5 No more blurry vision

    Unknown

    I was finding that if I used other eyeliners, my vision would get blurry. Not sure if this has anything do to with my gluten allergy but anyway, I tried Red Apple’s gluten free eyeliner and when I use it, I don’t get blurry vision! I use this pencil every day. It lasted me for months! It sharpens really nicely too. It draw extremely smooth. I sometimes heat up the end to help it glide on more easily but if you do this, make sure that the tip has cooled down a bit before using it on your eye! Don’t loose out. Buy it today.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  41. 5 out of 5 Thank you!! No Itching!

    Jennifer A.

    Oh yeah, I love this stuff! I just sent a photo via FaceBook of my little nubby pencil that I use so much. I have never, ever used a eyeliner pencil this much in my entire life. Thank you RAL for making a safe and healthy, non-itchy eyeliner pencil. I look forward to more wonderful RAL products – worth EVERY single cent I pay. (Concealer or mineral face powder perhaps?)

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  42. 5 out of 5 Non itchy eye liner

    Radie

    Finally! A product that does what it promises…..color works, easy to apply, no itching, no tears. Excellent!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  43. One person found this helpful

    4 out of 5 No Itch or burn but does not stay on long

    Katherine

    I have tried other “gluten free” eye liners and have still had itching and burning within a few hours. This eyeliner causes me absolutely no discomfort (and I am very very sensitive). The only problem is that it does not stay on or in place for long and then I get raccoon eyes. It does glide on soft without pulling.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  44. One person found this helpful

    3 out of 5 goes on creamy, but does smudge/flake on me

    Unknown

    This goes on easy and creamy. This always smudges into racoon eyes for me. Setting with an application of eyeshadow does help, but it doesn’t stay put on my lower eye. My eyes are deep set and 50 years old.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  45. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Great eyeliner

    Unknown

    If you’re looking for an eyeliner that won’t cause allergic reactions, that will stay put -even when it is August in Florida, then buy this product b/c it really is terrific It goes on easily & is easy to adjust its intensity. Definitely plan to buy it again.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  46. 5 out of 5 Astonishingly black-as-you-like-it Liner

    Jodi

    Being a very fair (think ‘color of skim milk’) lady, I have always been careful not to purchase black eyeliner, not wanting to look like I should be starring in the next Avril Lavigne music video. But I took a little risk and purchased this incredible liner–now, it’s my brown, my black, my wing-tip go-to liner. It is just shy of creamy, does not catch on my lids, stays all day, and is even great for wearing on the water line. What I love most about this eyeliner is that, just as all Red Apple lipsticks, I can vary the color by applying additional layers or pressing a bit harder. Do yourself a favor, add this liner to your makeup bag.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  47. 4 out of 5 Love it

    Jean

    I really love this eyeliner. I’ve used many different brands over the years and this is my favorite. I’m 50 and my eyes aren’t as smooth as they used to be, this eyeliner goes on smoothly for me without catching or pulling. I like that it’s a soft black and it goes with any eye shadow. I gave it 4 stars just because I haven’t tried to sharpen it yet.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  48. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 smooth application

    Mellan

    This eyeliner went on very smoothly without tugging at tender skin and with just the right amount of.color. In a flash my eyes were done! Since I am not in the habit of wearing makeup I forgot to.check throughout the evening or even when I got home to see how well it lasted. I will pay attention next time. Very nice!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  49. 5 out of 5 Eyeliner, Lipstick and Eye Shadow

    Marjorie

    I’ve recently purchased the eyeliner and lipstick after receiving the eye shadow as a gift. I have to say that I think these products are the best I’ve ever purchased. I’m sold now on Red Apple products and will continue using them. I can’t wait to try the mascara!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  50. 3 out of 5 Disapointed

    Jill

    I really had high hopes for this while it does not irate my eyes the color is just not as dark as I would like.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  51. 5 out of 5 Goes On Easily!

    Deanne

    I just received my 1st eyeliner from RAL last week and have been wearing it daily. I love the consistency of the pencil. It goes on easily and stays put all day. I would love a smudger at the opposite end though to make a sexier look. Now I am just waiting for more colors. I would love to see a chocolate brown, a navy and a deep green.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  52. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Eyeliner Smoothee

    Betty Hughes

    The new eyeliner is very smooth to apply and very black. I like the way it requires very little pressure and the only improvement would be a softener on the end for creating a softer/smoky look.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  53. 2 out of 5 Great eyeliner...until you sharpen it

    Unknown

    I was a fan when I tried this eyeliner for the first time. It was long lasting and I like that it was gluten free. When I tried to sharpen this pencil, I wasted half of the pencil because it kept crumbling. It was a brand new sharpener, so I don’t know what the problem was. Any advice on how to sharpen this or what type of sharpener to use?…

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  54. One person found this helpful

    3 out of 5 Smudges

    LR

    This is very creamy. Goes on fairly easily, but smudges easily.

    The point doesn’t hold up well since it is so creamy.

    Will have to see how it does if first apply Prime Time eye primer.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  55. 5 out of 5 Perfect Eye liner

    Unknown

    Love that this is gluten free. It doesn’t make my eyes water. Has great color and last all day.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  56. 3 out of 5 Works well as a base for eyeshadows

    Jody Liu

    I love that this product is natural and is made of safe ingredients,
    especially since it is something I put very very close to my eyes~ I
    also like that it is pigmented and the simple fact that it glides on
    easily.

    However, I didnt like that it isnt smudge-proof. In a weather as hot and
    humid as Singapore, this eyeliner starting smudging in less than 1 hour
    and I ended up with raccoon eyes! Hahaha~ That’s a big nono for me 🙁

    So now, I use it as a base for smokey look~ works and last longer for smokey eye makeup!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  57. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Best Eye Liner I've Tried

    Unknown

    The best thing about this eyeliner is that I can use it on the inside of my eye and not get blurred vision!! It goes on smooth and draws very nice. I love it and will only use this from now on. Sharpens beautifully too!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  58. 5 out of 5 Goes on easily, smoothly, and evenly

    Emily

    I use a black powder eyeliner for a softer everyday look, but use this pencil on top of the softer black powder to darken up the line and give the appearance of thicker lashes and bigger eyes for a night out. This works great to do “cat eyes” as well. It goes on very easily, smoothly, and evenly. I will be buying this again and again.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  59. 4 out of 5 Gluten Free Eye Liner

    Sharon Eachus

    I ordered the Eye Liner for 5 other women besides myself. Here are some of the reviews I received. Absolutely loved it. It stayed on better then my other one does. Needs a lot of sharpening, maybe they could put it in the same type of tube as the lip pencil where you twist it up and make the actual liner that small – would need less sharpening then. Smears to easy, but liked it, goes on very nice and lasts all day- I would buy it again. It doesn’t hurt to apply like my hard pencil. Still waiting on two o more reviews from two of the ladies. Will post those when I get them.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  60. 2 out of 5 Did I get the dud?

    Rebecca Forrest

    While it might be good for my skin, the one I got is not creamy and does
    not draw on smoothly. Could be my age (we shall say I

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  61. 5 out of 5 A

    Patty

    Fantastic, I recommend this product.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  62. 5 out of 5 Love it!

    Patrice

    The eyeliner is really easy to put on and creates a perfectly smooth line!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  63. 5 out of 5 First pencil liner that didn't smear!

    Sharon McRae

    I’ve tried this just once so far, over the new eye primer, and if have to say I was super impressed! It was pretty easy to apply, no dragging or smearing, and gave just the right intensity of color. I usually use the black RAL shallow as a liner, but wanted to try something a bit quicker and more portable as an alternate option. Over the primer, it stayed in place all day, even through crying when I chopped onions (which I do a lot since I’m a busy mom and I teach plant-based cooking classes)! Easy to remove, as well. Definitely will keep this in my rotation, and for super lasting power, I’m going to try layering the black shadow over it. Thanks for another great product, RAL,

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  64. 3 out of 5 Having Problems

    Sharon Eachus

    I seem to be having problems with the eyeliner. I love the way it is soft and smooth and goes on easily. However, it smudges easily and I have to reapply it a lot! My skin seems to love to absorb it. For this reason I have to give it a 3 instead of a 5 – I am sad.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  65. 5 out of 5 Goes on great!

    Kelsey

    I LOVE this eyeliner! I have very sensitive eyes and eye lids, and this eyeliner didn’t bother them one bit. I like it because you can smudge it a bit to give it a nice smokey look. This is the only eyeliner I’ll ever buy again!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  66. 2 out of 5 Not so great

    Unknown

    This pencil was hard to use and the color is murky.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  67. 5 out of 5 Fantastic for oily skin!

    Shanah McKnight

    This is one of the best eyeliners by far. On a daily basis, I only apply liner to my bottom lids. The problem with most liners is that I end up with raccoon eyes by 2pm. That is not the case with RAL’s pencil; it lasts clear into the evening (even after the gym). I honestly was surprised due to the fact it is hard for me to find a liner that stays put. I’ve found a keeper!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  68. 5 out of 5 SO SOFT and SMOOTH EYELINER

    Sharon E

    Love Love Love this eyeliner. Doesn’t make my eyes water or itch. Goes on smooth and SOFT. Unlike some eyeliner pencils that HURT when you use them. Also, washes off without a lot of scrubbing! Thank you

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  69. 5 out of 5 SO SMOOTH!

    Kellie

    I love this eyeliner! It is the smoothest applying eyeliner I have ever used .Goes on very easy.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  70. 5 out of 5 Best liner ever!

    Lydia

    I have tried many eye liners and I have to say that this one my favorite. Goes on great. I do have to touch it up at the end of the day. Doesn’t burn my eyes like others that I have used.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  71. 5 out of 5 The best

    Unknown

    I have to rave about this eyeliner. I have sensitive eyes because of allergies. I given up on eyeliner because it always made my eyes itchy and watery. I decided to try this one. Not only do my eyes look bigger and defined they don’t get itchy or watery. Glides on smoothly and is truly black. Love this product! Can’t wait for the mascara! 5 bid stars.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  72. 5 out of 5 Eyeliner again, at last!

    Mary

    I haven’t worn eyeliner since realizing I had serious skin issues associated with Celiac, so I was so excited when I heard about this product! For me, it is fantastic – goes on easily and smoothly, and stays put! I would recommend this to any of my friends with sensitive eyes.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  73. 5 out of 5 Love this eyeliner!

    RJ

    Every time I’ve received a new product from RAL I’ve been pleasantly surprised, and overjoyed to have makeup that not only is toxin-free, but that looks and feels great and is easy to use. I just started using the new eyeliner and it’s the same story! It goes on smoothly and evenly, looks great and stays on! This is a big find for me and now I’m looking forward to the new mascara (and maybe even foundation, just maybe?) Thank you so much RAL!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  74. 5 out of 5 great liner!

    Stephanie

    this liner glides on smoothly and doesn’t bleed. I am hoping for more colors soon (hint hint!)

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  75. 5 out of 5 Great!

    Karin

    Love love love your products.

    Excellent eyeliner- would live to see it in a “roll-up” (wood-shaving free) packaging like the “almost red” lip liner.

    Won me over for life…

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  76. 3 out of 5 Keep trying You'll get it!

    Becky G

    Love all your other products so was really looking forward to the eyeliner gluten free. I feel it needs to be a lot softer. It is so hard that it pulls on that delicate eye skin.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  77. 2 out of 5 Not for me

    MaryAnn

    This pencil faded a little after wearing it.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  78. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 This is THE best eyeliner ever!

    Karla

    I haven’t had grood luck in the past with pencil eyeliners because they wear off over the day, and just about disappear. This is totally different. The eyeliner goes on well, blends nicely, and stays put. You can put it on lightly to make it a dark gray, or heavier for black. It’s great!

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  79. 5 out of 5 Finally

    April Polichette

    I love this eyeliner. I wear eyeliner every day. I have tried many, many kinds of pencil and liquid liners ranging from discount store brands to higher end department store kinds. Like one other reviewer said, some looked good, some did not. Some didn’t irritate my eyes, and some did. Even another brand that carries makeup free of toxins and chemicals still irritated my eyes! And I don’t have particularly sensitive eyes, so that says a lot about that product. This is the perfect black shade, glides on effortlessly, and lasts well under normal circumstances. It is not by any means waterproof or a perfect all day wear as I do have to touch up sometimes. The no toxins, gluten, and animal testing make it good enough for me though! Please come out with more colors (a plum and brown would be awesome!!!) Thanks again RAL for always inventing new and safe cosmetics. Super fast shipping. Coupons all the time. This is a top notch company!!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  80. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Worth Every Penny

    Mari

    the eye pencil was a real hit with me. It was a soft pretty black, it
    did not make my eyes itch or water, and it did not come off until I took
    it off with makeup remover. It stayed on my eye lids for thirteen
    hours without smudging or fading. Previously, eye pencils tended to do
    that for me. Usually after a couple of hours tops, I had to reapply it.
    And again a few hours after that, and you get the idea. Great
    product! The texture was really good, I really love that pencil, and
    now I really can’t wait until the mascara comes out. This has been a
    great adventure discovering all the great products you make. The
    quality is unbelievable. I like that you only release products when
    they are perfect, and when it is time to release them. Thank you so
    much for the great products and the great Black Friday sale. I was
    waiting for that one. Thank you for allowing us to purchase great
    products at a really great price. They are truly worth every penny, and
    then some.

    Best wishes and Merry Christmas!

    Mari Schmidt

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  81. 5 out of 5 Very nice!

    Kathy

    I love your products!! The eyeliner is very nice. I haven’t used a pencil liner much through the years, and yours glides on very nice. Can put it on light or dark, that is what I like about it. And has not irritated my eyes at all.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  82. 5 out of 5 Love it! I am using it as an eye liner and brown filler!

    Shelly

    It works great for a brow liner as well! It stayed on the whole day. A little goes a long way. Looks natural as a brow filler as well. My brows are dark brown (almost a black). This product is smooth going on. Thank you for another great product!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  83. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 The Best

    Mari

    I first started wearing eyeliner when I was 14, and by now I must have tried them all. Some made my eyes tear, some made them water, and some made them tear and water; some made them itch, some looked nice and some did not. I have also tried cream liners, (itch), liquids, (double itch), cake liner, and pencils. Until this pencil came out, I didn’t realize how much I wanted it and needed it. For the past six months, I had been wetting RAL eye shadow and using that as a liner, and it did a great job. Initially I was going to buy the mascara, but since it wasn’t available yet, I tried this instead. I bought two and am I ever glad that I did. The color is a nice soft black. It isn’t the least bit harsh. It goes on pretty easily and The Color Stays Put. Cue the exclamation points. !!!!!!! That has never ever happened before. Usually when something goes on easily, it comes off just as easily. Not this wonderful liner. I applied it at eight yesterday morning, and it did not smear, smudge, or budge during a very long Saturday. I took it off at 9 p.m. using makeup remover, and then it did come off easily, but under normal circumstances it did not. Normally eye pencils tend to smear and fade on my oily skin, but not this time. This is quite probably number one on my desert island wish list. If you could take one thing to a dessert island with you, what would it be? This would be at the top of my list. I would get around the one thing rule by saying my huge makeup bag, which would hold all of my RAL products and an iPad, which I would need to order more RAL. If Jay and Andrea can get my makeup from Texas to Virginia in less than a week, I am pretty sure they could get it to that dessert island too! If you try nothing else new, try this. Give yourself a wonderful stocking stuffer, a Merry Christmas, and a Happy New Year. If they ever come out with other shades, and I hope they do, I will buy them all. Seriously. This is a classic shade, but it doesn’t mean I can’t crave other classic shades. Gray and taupe would be nice, but in the meantime, this is at the top of my reorder list. In a perfect world there would be this perfect eye pencil and the new mascara. Since we don’t live in a perfect world, the eye pencil is enough for now. It’s more than I ever imagined.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

×

I HAVE AN ACCOUNT

To make checkout quick and easy or to access an existing wishlist, please sign in below.

CREATE AN ACCOUNT

When you open a Red Apple Lipstick account, you'll be able to access Express Checkout, create a Wishlist, and see your order history online.

Password must meet the following requirements:

  • At least one letter
  • At least one capital letter
  • At least one number
  • Minimum 8 characters


Continue as a Guest

Don't have an account? Sign Up