Black Eyeliner Pencil by Red Apple

4.42 out of 5


Purchase this product now and earn 23 Points! Learn More

In stock

Return Policy: 6 Months

This eyeliner is designed without the yucky ingredients that cause allergic reactions and watery, puffy, itchy, red eyes.
Moisturizing and smooth – this pencil will glide against your lash line, which naturally makes your eyelashes look thicker and fuller at the base.
You will love the soft black color of this pencil – it will perfectly define your eyes – no muss no fuss!
Gluten Free, Paraben Free, Fragrance Free, Nut/Tree Nut Free, Corn Free, Soy Free – Toxin Free!


SKU: EP-1.

Black eyeliner is the quintessential makeup piece that everyone should own. Smudge it with your finger or eyeshadow for a natural or smokey eye or draw a thick line for a defined and bold look.

Either way, feel comfortable knowing that a Red Apple Eyeliner is not going to give you any weird reactions – it won’t smudge – and it won’t leave you with raccoon eyes at the end of the day!

Weight 0.25 oz
Dimensions 5 x .25 x .25 in
Allergen Information

Corn Free, Cruelty Free, Dairy Free, Nut Free / Fragrance Free, Petroleum Free

Each Red Apple Lipstick Product is hand crafted in the USA from the finest, highest quality materials available.

Each lineup has a slightly different set of ingredients and all cosmetics are lab tested 100% gluten free.

(net wt. .04 oz/1g)

Helianthus annus (Sunflower) seed oil, Synthetic Bees Wax, Copernicia Cerifera Wax, Rhus Succedanea Fruit Wax, GF Tocopheryl Acetate, Mica, Iron Oxides

Share your thoughts!

4.42 out of 5 stars

65 reviews

Help Another Woman By Posting Your Product Review Today. You can even add a picture or a video, it's fun!

What others are saying

  1. One person found this helpful

    5 out of 5 Best Eyeliner Ever, Hands Down!

    (verified owner)

    I was a little skeptical switching from my long lasting, drug store eye liners. I have tried so many eye liners, I swear I should be doing YouTube reviews. I had been a loyal “Almay ColorStay Eye Liner” user for years. I don’t know if I have oily skin or what but I can never seem to keep my eye liner from smudging. The Almay was the only one I used that would stay. After I had my son 2 years ago, I became allergic to many of the products I had used for years. After some research I started to realize just how bad the ingredients are in most products you buy at the drug store or even high-end like Sephora’s or Ulta. My eyes were always red, blood-shot, itchy and I just stopped wearing makeup all-together. When I learned about more natural options I tried 100 Percent Pure Eye Pencil first. It smudges pretty bad on me and I decided to try something else. I found Red Apple through a YouTube review of a natural, vegan YouTuber. I gave this pencil a try in the Black color. It came in last night, I put it on this morning and we are now in a committed relationship. It stayed on better than any eye liner I have ever used before in my life, my eyes were not irritated AT ALL. It felt like I wasn’t wearing it and it did not budge at all. Probably because I wasn’t itching my eyes like I normally do. You have my attention Red Apple. 🙂 <3

    Lipstick: Gypsy Soul
    Eyeliner: Black
    Lash Project Mascara in Black

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  2. 5 out of 5 Best Kohl-style Eyeliner I've Used

    (verified owner)

    I am thrilled to finally find a pencil eyeliner that stays. My eyes tear more often than I’d like, are highly sensitive…emphasis on highly sensitive, turn red and swollen at the slightest irritation….and this eyeliner works for me! I have had no reactions to wearing this pencil and it wears exceptionally well. I have used it along the top lash line as well as the lower lash line and it stays all day without smearing. When first applying each time I am aware that the pencil almost needs to warm up to go on smoothly on the upper lash line but after a couple of strokes it applies more smoothly and is not an issue; that is not a negative against the pencil for me as the alternative would be a super soft pencil and those are the style that smear and smudge. I will be purchasing this pencil in more colors just for the fun of it since I know they won’t smear. I have not found this quality of pencil at any level until now, so it pays to keep trying them out until you find one you like. I have used this loyally since I first tried it and this is the only black pencil liner I will use.

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  3. One person found this helpful

    4 out of 5 Love The Black Eyeliner But...

    (verified owner)

    For this to be an all natural eyeliner I had a great experience for the most part with this. I often run into trouble with eyeliners (natural or not) smearing down at the outer corners of my eyes and it would make me look tired and/or like I had a long day. This eyeliner does not BUT my problem with the eyeliner is when I get a little less than half way down the pencil, it all of a sudden requires a lot f sharpening but it’s not sharpening well. It starts to perform like a cheap 99 cents eyeliner rather than a $23 performance. I was irritated (as I was getting ready for work mind you) that the crayon (for lack of a better word) didn’t extend nearly all the way down the pencil. A little less than half way down the crayon stopped, so I definitely feel cheated because I’ve paid for expensive eyeliner before and the crayon extended nearly all the way down the pencil . I figured that must be why while sharpening as the pencil is a little less than half way down it’s hardly sharpening and nearly crumbling. I purchased it again anyway hoping that the previous was just defective. Other than that I think the pencil has great staying power but I hope you guys fix that issue in the pencil.

    (1) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  4. 4 out of 5 Love it

    (verified owner)

    I do have to say i love this, after years and years i finally found an eyeliner to put on my eyes that does not make my eyes blood red, puffy, itching, and end up giving me an headache a few hours later. The only thing that makes it not perfect, is the fact that it won’t stay on my water line, it moves down to my eyelash and under eye area leaving the water line almost “empty”… It’s not a huge deal, however it’s the only reason i don’t give this 5 stars! Because i do love this liner!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...

  5. 5 out of 5 The best

    I love the cocoa eyeliner. I use it every day. Soft, easy to put on and it stays!

    (0) (0)

    Something wrong with this post? Thanks for letting us know. If you can point us in the right direction...



To make checkout quick and easy or to access an existing wishlist, please sign in below.


When you open a Red Apple Lipstick account, you'll be able to access Express Checkout, create a Wishlist, and see your order history online.

Password must meet the following requirements:

  • At least one letter
  • At least one capital letter
  • At least one number
  • Minimum 8 characters

Don't have an account? Sign Up