Charcoal Eyeliner Pencil by Red Apple

Eyeliner goes on smooth and is visible all day long. It does transfer to the rest of my lid when I blink. I don't mind that so much because it looks intentional.

I love this pencil. I havent used eye liner in a while and was not sure how to use it. I googled and just did what felt right. I got lots of compliments on it.

Color is great! Not too dark, not too light. Neutral so goes with every eye color and shadow. Smooth application. No bees wax in it which is critical to me (allergy).

Excellent! This is the BEST eyeliner I’ve ever used. It goes on smoothly and has a silky feel. It stays put and doesn’t rub off like other eyeliners. Best of all, it’s completely allergen-free. I have really sensitive skin, and have never had any issues/ reactions. I highly recommend this product!

This eye pencil is a creamy medium-deep grey with no shimmer. It might have the tiniest blue undertone, which works very well with my pink porcelain skin tone. It glides on very smoothly, but it might be just a touch too soft (gets smeary on a very humid day). But when I press it into the lash line and smudge out with a very narrow angle brush, the pigment serves to visually thicken the lash line, such that I can skip mascara. I also like that this pencil is a multi tasker. Despite being very fair skinned and having low/medium contrast, now that my hair is changing from ash blonde to silver, I've been using Charcoal as brow filler. I can never seem to find brow pencils that are cool enough (all contain too much red or yellow, which does not flatter my pure ash brows). I lightly pencil in a few fine lines in the sparse areas, and then I use a brow brush to blend out, so the result isn't harsh. So one pencil frames my face and my eyelashes. Perfect.